Be persistent, patient and firm

When your insurer doesn't respond to a valid claim, it may be time to get tough. According to Bob Scott, an attorney with The Advocate Law Group, "When the process breaks down, policyholders should immediately stop dealing with their insurer over the phone and begin requesting written confirmation of any of the insurer's requests. In addition, policyholders can send letters to their insurance adjuster and the President of the company informing him or her about the delay. Unfortunately, phone calls often get ignored; but letters tend to get more attention. No matter how frustrating the process becomes, policyholders should always be persistent and polite, but firm." But what should you do when your insurer starts investigating YOU?

Case in point

A policyholder reported that his car had been stolen and cooperated with his insurance company every step of the way – being persistent, polite and firm. His car was found, but was badly banged up. Unfortunately for the policyholder, he did not have rental insurance and had to pay to rent a replacement vehicle while his insurance company processed the claim. He waited patiently. Then, he waited some more. His adjuster got back to him – but not with a resolution. Instead, he was asked to provide personal information such as credit card receipts, proof of income and even his mortgage information.

Clearly, the insurance company thought that this policyholder may have had something to do with the theft. However, what does his mortgage statement have to do with the claim? We don't know the answer to that, but it smells of bad faith…

Taking it the next level

Sometimes, even being persistent, patient and firm doesn't work. That's when you need to take your claim to the next level. Consider speaking with your adjuster's supervisor, the insurance commissioner or even the President of the insurance company. However, "Policyholders that find themselves in very difficult situations, such as a policyholder above who is himself being investigated, should contact a lawyer immediately", says Scott. "Insurance companies must deal with their policyholders in good faith. It is their duty. This case certainly seems like bad faith to me. In fact, I don't recall this type of aggressive claim response to a car theft. It is really outrageous."

Policyholders simply don't have to put up with this type of interrogation. It just isn't reasonable. Contact an attorney who can advocate on your behalf – especially one who understands how insurers operate.

Consumer tips

• Deal with your insurance company in good faith – provide them with the information they request – as long as it's reasonable.
• Be persistent, patient, but firm. You'll know when too much is too much.
• Put it in writing – letters tend to get more attention and also provide you with a written record of the claim.
• Take it to the next level. Don't be intimidated by bringing your claim to a supervisor's attention, reporting the matter to the President of the company or contacting your state's insurance commissioner.
• Seek the advice of an attorney. Don't spend your life trying to get somewhere with your insurance company. Turn the matter over to a qualified attorney who will act on your behalf – especially when your insurer acts in bad faith.

To contact an insurance bad faith attorney, click here.